LA HONDA, San Mateo County — November 12, 2026. A head-on collision on the winding Highway 84 near La Honda has led to a civil lawsuit naming Tesla, a Tesla employee and participants in a sports-car gathering. The plaintiff, Michelle Brooks, 70, says she suffered serious injuries when a Tesla-owned Model Y crossed into her lane on August 30. Her attorneys allege the driver was demonstrating the vehicle's performance at excessive speed after a nearby Cars & Coffee event. The allegations have not been proven in court, and a civil filing is not a finding of criminal guilt.
What the lawsuit alleges
San Francisco Chronicle reporting published November 12 identifies the Tesla employee as Micah Zuglian, and says the suit names car gathering group 9burgring, its founder Ethan Garabedian and a wine-bar business alongside the automaker. The plaintiff's attorneys say the test drive exceeded 80 mph on a mountainous road with posted limits around 35–40 mph; that speed is alleged by the plaintiff, not an independently certified speed reading supplied by California58. The Chronicle says Highway Patrol investigators confirmed a collision between the Tesla and Brooks's vehicle.
What the organizer says
In the Chronicle's reporting, Garabedian disputed the allegation that his gathering was responsible for the Tesla test drives, arguing they were organized independently by the company. He expressed sympathy for the injured driver. A separate Road & Track report outlines the legal claims against the defendants. The suit seeks damages and a jury trial; there has been no final adjudication of which parties, if any, are civilly liable.
What the crash says about Highway 84 safety
Residents and drivers have raised concerns about aggressive driving and car-meet traffic on the region's mountain routes for years. A single serious collision can motivate renewed safety scrutiny, but it does not establish that all gatherings create the same risk or that Tesla vehicles as a category are unsafe. Any evaluation must distinguish documented CHP collision findings, traffic volumes, posted speeds, actual speed measurements and roadway geometry from assertions in pleadings.
EDITORIAL FOLLOW-UP — November 12, 2026: La Honda News sent an information request to CHP's Office of Media Relations seeking publicly releasable details about the August 30 Highway 84 collision, investigative status and aggregated mountain-road safety data. No new official response has yet been received. The complaint's allegations and any future police findings remain separate.
Questions La Honda News will pursue
- What does the publicly releasable CHP collision report confirm about speed, centerline crossing, citations and collision mechanics?
- What written policies govern company vehicles used in promotional or test-drive demonstrations on public roads?
- Did organizers or property owners have a documented operational role in planning the specific test drives?
- What enforcement and engineering improvements are planned for Highway 84's most collision-prone curves?
- What court filings and future hearing dates will give the defendants an opportunity to answer the claims?
Sources: San Francisco Chronicle November 12 lawsuit coverage; Road & Track November 12 independent report. No verified original video of this August crash or current legal proceedings has been found, so La Honda News will not label a generic car video as footage of the crash. The newsroom welcomes public records and attributed responses from the parties at La Honda News.
Support La Honda News
Choose how to support La Honda News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “La Honda News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from La Honda News
- La Honda in Three Videos: Redwood Roads and the 2026 Water Pipeline Bypass Project →
- The Story Behind Sam McDonald Park: A Black Stanford Superintendent's Gift to Future Generations →
- La Honda Water Project Aims to Bypass Break-Prone Line Through Sam McDonald Park →
- Ridge Fire Road Near La Honda Will Close November 4–6 for Vegetation Management →
- La Honda News: San Francisco's October 21 Power Outage Was Not a Confirmed Mountain Outage →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.